[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Review Quiz #4
1. Hell is other people! (Because we hate being so dependent on them for acceptance of our identities.)
2. Garcin cannot leave because he must first convince Estelle and Inez that he is the tough guy that he thinks he is. We are desperate for people to recognize us as what we think we are.
3. Estelle needs her mirror, because a mirror is how superficial people try to control how other people see them, and so, without it, her identity is up for grabs. And even if you aren’t purely superficial, we all still try to control the “self” we portray to others, whether it is Jeff’s “I’m a kind nerd” or your “I want people to see me as someone who doesn’t care what they think.” (Wicked irony, eh?)
4. We spend a ton of effort altering our looks and buying things to get other people to accept us as the person we want to be (and this person is often a lie, such as working class people trying to look rich by buying iphones). The car, clothes, gadgets are tools for our social performance that is trying to get people to see us as the social identity we are trying to portray. And even if you aren’t purely superficial, we all still try to control the “self” we portray to others.
5. The basic definiton of Bad Faith is “a lie to oneself” (even though that seems impossible).
6. The waiter doesn’t “have to” do any of this. What we choose is a choice to value that thing, and he won’t admit that he is choosing tips over being himself or doing something else for money. He makes the choice to act like a robot for tips instead of choosing to be himself, value authenticity over money, get another job, be nice because it makes others happy, etc.
7. The girl on the date is lying that her date only wants sex, so that she doesn’t have to make a choice. She pretends his comment about her looks isn’t manipulative and even ignores his first move of holding her hand.
8. The girl on the sate is lying to deny that her date is manipulative and insincere so that she can believe the fantasy that he cares about her as a person and feel good about herself. She makes several psychological moves to avoid this reality that is calling for her decision.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Review Quiz #3
1. Since I am thinking abut this crazy question as my current task, this question and how to word my answer to it are phenomenologically closest to me right now. Whereas my self, my computer, my keyboard … all fade into the ready-to-hand background.
2. A steering wheel normally appears as an everyday tool I can just take for granted (i.e. ready-to-hand). It barely appears at all…it is “just” a steering wheel. The other items are not normally taken for granted but are more mysterious and disrupt our mindless projects.
3. Death normally appears as in-the-way of my tasks and something I have to figure out (present-at-hand)…death breaks all of our projects. The other objects are normal things we don’t give much thought to and just use.
4. If math or my job is directly related to my life goals (you will need this math in your career or your job is in your career field), then to concentrate on my current task I have to let those goals fade into the background of my thoughts. This can be bad, because I might lose sight of those goals. For most people, however, math class and their job are not connected to their goals and those goals do not appear at all (they are no-thing) except when daydreaming. This is really bad because you are likely to continue at these irrelevant tasks and never reach anything you seek.
5. Present-at-hand is how broken or missing tools appear. So the correct answer is not the tool, but how it appears… They appear as objective things that must be studied to repair them back to the ready-to-hand. (Very rarely these present-at-hand experiences can lead to seeing what the tool and projects are for and allow you to evaluate the value of the project in full.)
6. “I am” the They. Remember, the They is everyone and oneself, but always no one in particular. The They cannot be located as a definite thing, whereas the other choices are definite things. This is the worst thing about the They, that is, that it cannot be ignored or defied, because it is not definable, but we know what it thinks, because it is what we think. (spooky)(Note: Some of you answered “All of the above”, which is a pretty good answer as well, because The They is everyone and no one. I mean, The They can’t be pointed out, so this isn’t as good of an answer, because the other answers are things we can identify.)
7. If death became truly present-at-hand this would mean we are studying death objectively and realizing that all of our current projects are breaking, and this, if Jeff’s hopes are realized, would allow us to see all of the projects behind our everyday tasks and evaluate them to assess their worth. “Since I am dying (hint: we all are, by the way), do I really want to do this task to achieve that goal? Wait, I am not even working toward any of the goals that matter. Damn it! Please help me Jeff.” (Or, you know, something like that.)
8. The They says, “Sure, death will happen to you, but not soon, so don’t think about it. You have plenty of time to take control of your life someday. For now, just keep working at the Krusty Krab to buy another companion cube.” (Note: Krusty Krab = your job; companion cube = your phone)

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Review Quiz #2
1. My belief is only true if it agrees with reality. (Some might say that it is evidence or proof that makes something true, but that is not quite right, because our evidence could be mistaken. Think of those who thought the sun revolved around the earth: they thought this because it looks like the sun is moving. It is reality that makes a claim true, not the evidence or proof.)
2. The idea of “personal truth” or some belief being “true to me” is saying no more than “I believe this” or “This is my perspective”. And, of course, your believing something has no bearing on whether it agrees with reality. People believe false things or are deceived by their limited perspective constantly.
3. We should judge others’ values when they are irrational and when they could harm others. This can be done fairly by judging others’ values based on their own consistency, that is, we can judge someone’s values as being irrational if they are inconsistent with reality and/or inconsistent with their own values. (We are not judging others based on our own values.)
4. Jeff immediately grows a glorious beard. (I am so ashamed of my immaturity.)
5. The Cave story mocks the “seeing is believing” mindset, because it shows the cave-dwellers (most people) staring at illusions and taking them for reality. If all you see is deception, then your beliefs will be delusions. And, in Plato’s view, the whole physical world of sight is deceptive.
6. Normal science studies things in the physical world. In the cave story, these would be the shadows, and thus science, to Plato, is just playing the “shadow game” of naming and predicting the shadows. (Now, don’t overstate this, you people who deny science in the name of astrology or religion or conspiracies… scientists are better at dealing with the physical world than you, but they are not experts when it comes to abstract knowledge.)
7. Our everyday, physical world is untrustworthy for three reasons (pick two): 1. The world is always changing, 2. Our perspectives are always changing, and 3. The theories we use to interpret the world are always changing. (But, note, that doesn’t mean that objective truth doesn’t exist in Plato’s view; it just isn’t found using everyday perception. It is found in the realm of ideals, like math and philosophy.)
8. Philosophy is the study of presuppositions in all fields of knowledge. The Cave prisoners are us, and their stupidity and stubbornness about their assumptions should inspire us to want to study philosophy to check our assumptions so that we can avoid errors and escape our oppressive caves.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Deja,
If you wish there was a good spinoff of Friends, I love “Happy Endings”, and the Brits made a short series called “Coupling” that is very good.
Jeff

• This reply was modified 3 weeks ago by jsalbato@cnm.edu.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

I can second this recommendation. Pho Bar is great. Just be forewarned (or thrilled if you are like me) that some of their Pho portions are huge.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Robert,
I’ve been downsizing my book collections over the last couple of years. I’ve given away most of them already, but there are still some of my philosophy books that are harder to read and so harder to give away to a normal reader, so tell me what are your favorite sub-disciplines so that I can see if I have some books left you might want.
Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Review Quiz #1
1. The tasks for each week are listed at the top of our webpage: In order: (1) Do the reading while (2) answering the Reading Questions, then (3) use Jeff’s lectures to correct and add clarity to your answers, then (4) take the Friday Quiz.
2. The absolute deadline for quizzes and exams is Saturday at noon.
3. The best prep for the Friday quizzes is the Reading Questions, because most of the quiz comes straight from those questions. (Note: But please be sure to read the questions carefully, because there are some subtle differences from the reading questions that I want you to think about. You can paste some of your reading questions answers straight over, but this won’t work for all of the quiz questions.)
4. The Friday quizzes cannot be made up, but there are many extra points built into the class to make up for missing a quiz or two. These extra points are built into every quiz and exam (they are not extra credit assignments).
5. Grades are based on earning points. For example, a “B” is earned when you get 80 points. (Note: It is not a percentage; that’s way harder. Out of the 130 possible points, 80 points is only 61%…you see, Jeff is a softy).
6. Philosophy is the study of the presuppositions in all fields of thought. (Note: Philosophy is the home of genuine critical thinking, carefully checking the support for all of our ideas, even the ones that we assume are obvious.)

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Edith,
I just recommended the book “Me Before You” in the book forum, and “Crazy, Stupid, Love” is brilliant
Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Eboni,
I grew up surfing and my wife is into scuba diving, so I get it. When we retire in a couple years we’re planning on taking up kayaking and moving each year to different watery places in the Eastern U.S..
– Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Zaira,
Thanks. I just added “Flipped” to my book and watch list. Don’t tell anyone, because I am such a serious person and serious scholar, but I have recently been binging Romance books. My favorites: Moyes’ “Me Before You” and Hoang’s “Kiss Quotient” (the latter gets raunchy, so you’re forewarned). And, yes, I also read a bunch of Emily Henry; they’re pretty good. Okay, now stop making me admit any of this reading. I’m, like, serious and heartless and stuff, right?
– Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Hi Lainey,
My genius, scientist daughter has dyslexia as well, but she is an audiobook fiend. Yep, you should get back into it.
Also, I studied quite a bit of Christian apologetics in my younger days and at seminary. I no longer call myself a Christian because of what these Trump years have shown me, but I can still be a good source of information about the study of the Bible and apologetics.
– Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Veggie Tales rules!

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Sebastian,
I kneel before you. I pretend to love cooking and food, but you actually know about it. And now you are going to know about philosophy, too. Triple threat. Sigh.
– Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Payton,

Yes and yes.

Stardew Valley is in my original post. That game is adored by all.

And I am impressed with your recommendation of Apiary. That game is well-reviewed. I haven’t played it, but that is similar to games I play, like Spirit Island, Viticulture, Wingspan, Lost Ruins of Arnak.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

I chickened out of playing Captain Sonar with some strangers at a board game event. I was just too a-scared. But it looks brilliant. If my board game group met more often, I would definitely buy that game.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

A bunch of my favorite games are Minecraft-adjacent. Satisfactory is minecraft with engineering and graphics. Planet Crafter is minecraft with terraforming. But if you’re more of a purist, Minecraft-ions usually love Terraria.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Chris,
Crazy coincidence…just yesterday I was looking “Suits” up on IMDB, because I was considering rewatching it. It’s phenomenal.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Woohoo! Virginia rules. Coda Bakery and Pollito con Papas were in my original post, too. Must tries! You’ll thank us.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Oooh, thanks Saada! Yoshi Mame looks great. I just put it on my list of places to try.

The other great affordable Japanese place is Nagomi. And, I know this is hard to believe, but when Sushi King has their all-you-can-eat days, it is pretty great and a deal, too.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Very cool. When I was poorer, I would buy a basic PC and then slowly rebuild it piece by piece until it was capable to game on. But I never built one from scratch. You are way cooler than me.

And the other thing I used to do is turn family members’ old, slow laptops into speedy Linux machines without them knowing it wasn’t still Windows. (Story: My sister-in-law thinks she knows everything and was trying to help my father-in-law connect his new printer to his laptop. Ha! She didn’t even realize it was Linux when she had to call me for help.)

Nowadays I just buy a solid rig and then add the easy stuff to make it sing.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

John,
Yep, that is how I nerd out on all my hobbies. And those are the best memories of my Dad. Him nerding out on fly fishing or carpentry is when he was the happiest.
-Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Yes! “The Middle” is brilliant. And yes, Sue is a hero in our family.

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Ellie! You rule.

Gladwell’s “Blink” is my favorite book of his.

And I just added Walker’s “Complex PTSD” to my book list. I haven’t found a great book on that topic, and that one seems brilliant.

-Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Landon,
La Guelaguetza looks genius. I wish it was near me. My wife is a Mexican food snob… if a joint doesn’t make their own chips and taco shells that place is despised. When I show her this spot, she’ll be stoked.
-Jeff

[jsalbato@cnm.edu]

Kayla,
I have “What We Do In The Shadows” in my shows to watch list. I can’t wait to start it.
-Jeff

[Author]

Posts